Skip to content

Emergency repairs 24/7 Booked jobs Mon to Sun, 8AM to 8PM

A toilet that never quite stops filling

It is almost always one of four things inside the tank, and there is a test that proves which in half an hour without tools.

By Hamza Rivera, updated

Short answer: A toilet that keeps filling is almost always one of four things inside the tank: the flapper or flush valve seal, the chain length, the fill valve or the float height. Put a few drops of food colouring in the tank and wait half an hour without flushing. Colour in the bowl means the flush valve seal is leaking.

If the bowl fills and will not go down, that is a blockage rather than a running tank: how to unclog a toilet without a plumber.

If your toilet has no tank, this is not your fault to find

Every guide to this describes the same repair: take off the tank lid, check the flapper, adjust the fill valve, shorten the chain. Home Depot opens by telling you to turn off the supply and hold the handle down.

A pail-flushed bowl has no tank, no flapper and no fill valve. It cannot run. If water is moving in your house with nothing being used, it is the supply line, a tank somewhere else or a fitting, and the meter will find it faster than the bathroom will.

The test that settles it

Put a few drops of food colouring in the tank. Leave it half an hour and do not flush. Then look in the bowl.

Colour in the bowl means the flush valve seal is passing, and that is your leak. No colour means the tank is not leaking into the bowl and you should be looking at the fill valve and the overflow instead. It costs nothing and it needs no tools.

The four things it is

Cut-away of a toilet cistern A side view through a toilet tank with the lid off. Water sits about an inch below the top of an open overflow tube in the middle. On the left a handle connects by a chain to a rubber flapper seated over the flush valve at the bottom, which drains to the bowl. On the right a fill valve carries a float that rides on the water surface and shuts the valve off. Four numbered markers mark the flapper seal, the chain, the fill valve and the float, which are the four causes described below the drawing in the same order. lid off water line about an inch overflow tube handle flapper down to the bowl fill valve float supply in 1 2 3 4

Drag the drawing sideways to see all of it.

Four things make a tank run, and every one of them is inside the lid. The numbers here are the four below, in the same order. Drawn for a tank cistern. A pail-flushed bowl has none of these parts, which is why the fault cannot be this one.

The flapper or flush valve seal

The rubber seal at the bottom of the tank has hardened or warped, so it no longer seats. The most common cause by a wide margin, the cheapest part, and the one the food colouring test proves.

The chain is too short or too long

Too short and it holds the flapper slightly open. Too long and it tangles under the flapper. Both cause the same symptom and neither needs a new part.

The fill valve will not shut off

The tank fills past its mark and pours down the overflow tube forever. You can see this one: look for water running into the open pipe in the middle of the tank.

The float is set too high

The same result as a failed fill valve, from a different cause. The water level should sit about an inch below the top of the overflow tube, and the float is adjustable.

Here, the symptom is often the pump

This is the part no other page on the subject will tell you, because it assumes a pressurised mains supply.

If your house is fed from a roof tank, a leaking flush valve does not announce itself as a noise in the bathroom. It drains the roof tank quietly, and the pump refills it. So what you actually notice is the pump cutting in at two in the morning, or the tank never staying full. Same fault, completely different symptom, and it is the most common reason a bill goes up with nothing visibly dripping anywhere.

How a silent toilet leak becomes the pump's habit The chain drawn left to right. The toilet's tank, its flush seal passing quietly into the bowl. Above and to the right, the roof tank that feeds it, drawn with its level fallen below an old level line. Further right, the pump that refills the roof tank, cutting in on its own. Beside it, the water meter, which counts every refill. Nothing in the chain makes a sound in the bathroom. passing quietly into the bowl the roof tank, falling the pump, cutting in at odd hours, on its own the meter sees it

Drag the drawing sideways to see all of it.

The chain, drawn. The flush seal passes quietly into the bowl, the roof tank feeding it falls, the pump refills the roof tank on its own schedule, and the meter counts every refill. Nothing in this chain makes a sound in the bathroom, which is why the pump is the part you notice and the meter is the part that proves it.

Where it stops being a part you can change

  • A new flapper that still passes, which usually means the seat it sits on is pitted or scaled rather than the rubber being at fault.
  • Water at the base of the bowl rather than inside the tank. That is the wax seal or the closet flange, and it is a different job that involves lifting the toilet.
  • A concealed cistern behind a wall or inside a vanity, where getting to the parts is most of the work.
  • A pump that is short cycling after the toilet is fixed. That is the pump or its pressure tank, and if the fault is electrical it is an electrician's work rather than ours.

Questions about a toilet that keeps running

My toilet has no tank. Can it still run?

No, and that is worth knowing before you go looking. A pail-flushed bowl has no tank, no flapper and no fill valve, so there is nothing to leak from and nothing to keep refilling. If water is moving somewhere with nothing being used, it is coming from the supply line, a tank elsewhere in the house, or a fitting, not from the bowl.

How do I prove it is the toilet without taking anything apart?

Put a few drops of food colouring in the tank, leave it half an hour without flushing, then look in the bowl. If the colour has arrived in the bowl, the flush valve seal is passing and that is your leak. It costs nothing, takes no tools, and it is the one test that settles the argument.

Why does my pump keep starting when nobody is using water?

On a house fed from a roof tank, a leaking flush valve drains that tank quietly, and the pump refills it. So the symptom you notice is not a running toilet but a pump cutting in at two in the morning. It is the same fault, and it is the reason a high bill often has no visible drip anywhere in the house.

What does a running toilet actually waste?

Far more than a dripping tap, which is why it is worth chasing. A flush valve passing steadily can lose several litres an hour, so the number to check is your meter rather than your intuition. Take two readings with nothing in use and work out the rate before assuming it is small.

Still running? Send it to us

Four things and we can get back to you. The more you put here, the less there is to work out when we do.

We ring or message you back on this number. Nothing else is sent to it.

We reply here in writing, and use it for nothing else.

Your town or barangay helps us send whoever is nearest.

If you would rather chat

A written message reaches us with the detail already in it, so we know what is wrong before we ring you back. For a quick question first, the chat button sits in the corner of every page.

Monday to Sunday, 8AM–8PM
Emergency Repairs Available 24/7

Silent, and the most expensive one

A running toilet wastes more than anything else in a house and makes no noise doing it. Send us the problem and say what the colouring test showed.

Emergency repairs 24/7 Booked jobs Mon to Sun, 8AM to 8PM

Send the problem Chat
Message us

Message us

Ask about a job, an area or what something costs. We reply by email or ring you back.